Skip to content
Home » Polar Daylight Wellbeing Guide » What causes Seasonal Affective Disorder? Deep-dive into circadian mismatch

What causes Seasonal Affective Disorder? Deep-dive into circadian mismatch

    Sea­son­al Affec­tive Dis­or­der (SAD) is the sci­en­tif­ic term for sea­son­al depres­sion, most often occur­ring in win­ter. One can debate at length the rel­e­vance of the SAD con­cept, the per­ti­nence and reli­a­bil­i­ty of its diag­no­sis. Most impor­tant­ly, some sea­son­al symp­toms are observed among pop­u­la­tions resid­ing in the North of the North­ern Hemi­sphere, where sig­nif­i­cant sea­son­al fluc­tu­a­tions in day­light dura­tion pre­vail: low mood or decreased ener­gy lev­els. SAD has been diag­nosed since the mid-1980s. A sem­i­nal arti­cle from that era spec­i­fies: «Dur­ing the win­ter affect­ed indi­vid­u­als feel depressed, slow down, and gen­er­al­ly over­sleep, overeat, and crave car­bo­hy­drates.» (Rosen­thal, 1985) Even­tu­al­ly, whether the occur­rence of such symp­toms is sub­sumed under the win­ter depres­sion or SAD con­cept seems of lit­tle sig­nif­i­cance; for the sake of sim­plic­i­ty we will call SAD any com­bi­na­tion of those symp­toms: in short, win­ter mood and rhythm swings.


    Winter sunlight

    «Win­ter depres­sion». What is «win­ter»? Sea­sons are pri­mar­i­ly the effect of the tilt of Earth­’s axis rel­a­tive to the orbital plane of its rota­tion around the sun. This incli­na­tion caus­es, at a giv­en lat­i­tude, a fluc­tu­a­tion dur­ing the year in day length and in sun angle – or equiv­a­lent­ly, the alti­tude of the Sun at solar noon. In turn these affect the amount of heat ener­gy received per Earth­’s sur­face unit at a giv­en lat­i­tude. Thus, «win­ter» is a sea­son­al «cli­mate change» result­ing from over­all less heat ener­gy per day per Earth­’s sur­face unit from solar radi­a­tion, as a result of the low sun angle induc­ing more indi­rect, low­er inten­si­ty light, as well as of reduced day­light hours.

    Pal­las­tun­turi fells dur­ing sun­set in Muo­nio, Lap­land, Fin­land in Jan­u­ary. Cred­it: Ximon­ic (Simo Räsä­nen)

    Geographical cold

    Cli­mate of north­ern or polar regions there­fore dif­fers dou­bly from more south­ern or equa­to­r­i­al regions: i. the sea­sons there are more pro­nounced, which, as we have just seen, is the result of the Earth­’s tilt on its axis; ii. these regions are also cold­er (gen­er­al­ly, year-round). Here, the cause is not the Earth­’s axi­al tilt, but the spher­i­cal shape of the Earth and its orbit around the sun (see Fig. 1)

    Win­ter depres­sion must have as its cause or trig­ger «some­thing that win­ter brings». It could be the cold and iso­la­tion. But the cold of the poles – rel­a­tive to the south and the equa­tor – is per­sis­tent and not sea­son­al. It seems to be estab­lished that win­ter sun­light – short­er day­light dura­tion and dim­mer light from a low­er sun – is the major cul­prit.


    From light to mood

    The pio­neer­ing study by Rosen­thal et al. men­tioned pre­vi­ous­ly intu­it­ed the impor­tance of light in the devel­op­ment of sea­son­al depres­sion. What put them on this track? Light is known as being an impor­tant «sea­son­al time cue in ani­mals». As a result of their inves­ti­ga­tion, the authors «found that win­ter depres­sion improved when patients were exposed to bright full-spec­trum light before dawn and after dusk, there­by extend­ing the pho­tope­ri­od.» If tweak­ing the pho­tope­ri­od – the dura­tion of bright light expo­sure dur­ing the day – helps with win­ter depres­sion, light must be close­ly linked to the phe­nom­e­non. (Rosen­thal, 1985)

    ⋙ Read about light ther­a­py for Sea­son­al Affec­tive Dis­or­der

    Along which bio­log­i­cal path­ways would light and pho­tope­ri­od influ­ence mood?

    Life on Earth, from bac­te­ria to com­plex organ­isms, is pret­ty much syn­chro­nized to a cycle of approx­i­mate­ly 24 hours – a cir­ca­di­an rhythm. In ani­mals, such a rhythm is not lim­it­ed to sleep-wake cycles, but also appears at the lev­el of bio­log­i­cal process­es in cells and organs. Although bio­log­i­cal cycles are endoge­nous – that is, main­tained by the organ­ism itself in the absence of envi­ron­men­tal stim­uli – «pow­er­ful exter­nal stim­uli [can] influ­ence and fine-tune» them: «in humans the most pow­er­ful of these exter­nal stim­uli has been shown to be day­light.» (Brainard, 2015) Light influ­ences mood because it affects the cir­ca­di­an bio­log­i­cal cycles of cells, organs, and bod­i­ly func­tions.

    It is the prac­ti­cal effec­tive­ness of light ther­a­py treat­ment for SAD symp­toms that ulti­mate­ly reveals the close link between lim­it­ed win­ter sun­light, cir­ca­di­an cycle dis­rup­tion, and win­ter depres­sion. A study (Lewy, 2006) for­mu­lates and tests the so-called phase-shift hypoth­e­sis.


    Circadian biology and sleep/wake cycles mismatch

    «The PSH [Phase-Shift Hypoth­e­sis] pos­tu­lates that most SAD patients become depressed in the win­ter because of the lat­er dawn, caus­ing their cir­ca­di­an rhythms to delay with respect to clock time and with respect to the sleep/wake cycle.» The cor­rec­tion of this phase delay through light ther­a­py is sig­nif­i­cant and strong­ly cor­re­lat­ed with improve­ment in sea­son­al depres­sion. Nev­er­the­less, this cor­re­la­tion is not suf­fi­cient, the study authors note, to prove the causal link between phase-shift and SAD – in oth­er words, the impor­tant «cir­ca­di­an com­po­nent of SAD». (Lewy, 2006)

    What does it mean pre­cise­ly for «cir­ca­di­an rhythms to delay with respect to clock time and with respect to the sleep/wake cycle»? How do we assess «cir­ca­di­an rhythms» and their «delay»?

    Melatonin as an evidence

    The most com­mon­ly used mark­er for assess­ing endoge­nous cir­ca­di­an phase posi­tion in humans is a mark­er of the time for the (cir­ca­di­an) evening rise of plas­ma mela­tonin lev­els. (Lewy, 2006; Ter­man, 2001) More pre­cise­ly, this mark­er is the dim light mela­tonin onset (DLMO), as we sam­ple plas­ma lev­els under con­di­tions of dim light to avoid sup­pres­sion of its pro­duc­tion, with a plas­ma lev­el thresh­old usu­al­ly set at 10pg/ml. (Fig. 2)

    Fig. 2. Endoge­nous mela­tonin pro­file and sleep pat­tern in a healthy sub­ject. Dim light mela­tonin onset (DLMO) is defined here as «the inter­po­lat­ed time of con­tin­u­ous rise [of plas­ma mela­tonin lev­els] above the thresh­old of 10 pg/ml; for exam­ple, if the mela­tonin lev­el at 8 p.m. was 5pg/ml and at 8:30 p.m. was 15 pg/ml, the DLMO would be 8:15 p.m» PAD stands for phase-angle dif­fer­ence, by def­i­n­i­tion the DLMO/mid sleep inter­val, assess­ing the phase-shift between cir­ca­di­an and sleep/wake cycle. (Lewy, 2006, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0602425103)

    Ulti­mate­ly, patients with win­ter depres­sion most gen­er­al­ly exhib­it altered onset dura­tion and off­set of mela­tonin secre­tion as com­pared to healthy sub­jects – typ­i­cal­ly, a lat­er DLMO and there­by a short­er phase-angle dif­fer­ence (PAD), defined as the inter­val between DLMO and mid-sleep. (Lewy, 2006; Ter­man, 2001)

    Not only light ther­a­py helps, Lewy shows, but also mela­tonin admin­is­tra­tion – the «chem­i­cal sig­nal of dark­ness» – typ­i­cal­ly tak­en in the evening for the major­i­ty of patients who present a DLMO delay (while a minor­i­ty presents a DLMO advance and would ben­e­fit from morn­ing mela­tonin). This con­firms that light ther­a­py mit­i­gates SAD via the mit­i­ga­tion of cir­ca­di­an rhythm dis­rup­tion – in oth­er words, it con­firms the cir­ca­di­an com­po­nent to SAD. (Lewy, 2006)

    ⋙ Read about light ther­a­py for Sea­son­al Affec­tive Dis­or­der


    Circadian pacemaker

    We said that the mela­tonin pro­duc­tion cycle «marks» cir­ca­di­an rhythm. But which cir­ca­di­an cycles are involved in win­ter depres­sion and through what path­ways are they impact­ed?

    We must look first at a small region of the brain in the hypo­thal­a­mus that is proven to be the cir­ca­di­an rhythms orches­tra­tor or pace­mak­er: the suprachi­as­mat­ic nuclei (SCN). It is locat­ed just above the optic chi­asm. Its neu­rons fire on day­light. More pre­cise­ly, «day­light stim­u­lates melanopsin recep­tors in reti­nal gan­glion cells and these cells trans­form the phys­i­cal sig­nal into an elec­tri­cal sig­nal that stim­u­lates the [SCN’s] neu­rons». (Brainard, 2015)

    The elec­tri­cal sig­nal acti­vates intra­cel­lu­lar sig­nal­ing path­ways that induce the tran­scrip­tion of cir­ca­di­an genes includ­ing Peri­od (Per), Cryp­tochrome (Cry), Clock, and Bmal1 in the SCN and sub­se­quent­ly in all periph­er­al organs through neur­al and hor­mon­al sig­nals. These genes are tran­scribed and trans­lat­ed into cir­ca­di­an pro­teins (PER, CRY, CLOCK, BMAL1) that impact SAD direct­ly by dys­reg­u­lat­ing neu­ro­trans­mit­ter rhythms or indi­rect­ly via mela­tonin dys­reg­u­la­tion and cir­ca­di­an phase mis­align­ment. (McClung, 2007; Dang, 2024)

    Note that fur­ther research nuances the orches­trat­ing pre­rog­a­tive of the SCN and indi­cates a sys­tem of «periph­er­al clocks» that receive time-of-day infor­ma­tion from the SCN to then ful­fill tis­sue-spe­cif­ic reg­u­la­tion. There­by «desyn­chro­niza­tion not only occurs between the exter­nal envi­ron­ment and the SCN rhythm gen­er­a­tor but also affects phase align­ments between the dif­fer­ent periph­er­al clocks.» (Edery, 2000)

    Inter­est­ing­ly, lit­er­a­ture also binds cir­ca­di­an genes expres­sion to anx­i­ety and mood dis­or­ders : there might be a cir­ca­di­an com­po­nent in depres­sion in gen­er­al – not just the win­ter one. (Dang, 2024; Walk­er, 2020; Fran­cis, 2023)


    What causes winter depression?

    Lim­it­ed day­light dura­tion and inten­si­ty, it seems, caus­es SAD via the dereg­u­la­tion of cir­ca­di­an rhythms. Research shows cir­ca­di­an dis­rup­tion, more pre­cise­ly a mis­match or phase-shift between bio­log­i­cal cir­ca­di­an rhythms and the sleep/wake cycle caus­es SAD. Day­light in turn is a key stim­u­lus to cir­ca­di­an tim­ing sys­tems via the acti­va­tion of the SCN’s neu­rons.

    Any­thing dis­turb­ing cir­ca­di­an clocks is then a poten­tial cause or aggra­vat­ing fac­tor to SAD. In some stud­ies mela­tonin admin­is­tra­tion cor­rects both cir­ca­di­an rhythms and SAD, so that a dis­rup­tion in the path­ways of mela­tonin pro­duc­tion, and any cause for it, can be a fur­ther cul­prit.

    But sci­en­tif­ic lit­er­a­ture hints at oth­er envi­ron­men­tal cues to phys­i­o­log­i­cal cir­ca­di­an clocks to reset and coor­di­nate. Notably, the inter­twin­ing of meal time with cir­ca­di­an clocks is well doc­u­ment­ed. Late eat­ing time could pro­mote cir­ca­di­an rhythms dis­rup­tion. (Klevens, 2025) Skip­ping break­fast might dys­reg­u­late bio­log­i­cal clocks: «the first meal of the day, con­sumed at the begin­ning of the activ­i­ty phase […] is a pow­er­ful “zeit­ge­ber”, or starter of periph­er­al clock genes expres­sion». (Jakubow­icz, 2023) Most inter­est­ing­ly, some impor­tant nutri­ents could be such time giv­ing cues as well. Is fat­ty fish an obvi­ous cure to SAD?


    References

    Rosen­thal, N. E., Sack, D. A., Car­pen­ter, C. J., Par­ry, B. L., Mendel­son, W. B., & Wehr, T. A. (1985). Anti­de­pres­sant effects of light in sea­son­al affec­tive dis­or­der. Amer­i­can Jour­nal of Psy­chi­a­try, 142(2), 163–170. https://doi.org/10.1176/ajp.142.2.163

    Brainard, J., Gob­el, M., Scott, B., Koep­pen, M., & Eck­le, T. (2015). Health impli­ca­tions of dis­rupt­ed cir­ca­di­an rhythms and the poten­tial for day­light as ther­a­py. Anes­the­si­ol­o­gy, 122(5), 1170–1175. https://doi.org/10.1097/ALN.0000000000000596

    Lewy, A. J., Lefler, B. J., Emens, J. S., & Bauer, V. K. (2006). The cir­ca­di­an basis of win­ter depres­sion. Pro­ceed­ings of the Nation­al Acad­e­my of Sci­ences, 103(19), 7414–7419. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0602425103

    Ter­man, J. S., Ter­man, M., Lo, E. S., & Coop­er, T. B. (2001). Cir­ca­di­an time of morn­ing light admin­is­tra­tion and ther­a­peu­tic response in win­ter depres­sion. Archives of Gen­er­al Psy­chi­a­try, 58(1), 69–75. https://doi.org/10.1001/archpsyc.58.1.69

    Klevens, A., Tay­lor, M., Roeck­lein, K., & Wescott, D. (2025). 0041 Greater depres­sion sever­i­ty is asso­ci­at­ed with lat­er cir­ca­di­an eat­ing time in those with sea­son­al depres­sion. Sleep, 48(Supplement_1), A18. https://doi.org/10.1093/sleep/zsaf090.0041

    McClung, C. A. (2007). Cir­ca­di­an genes, rhythms and the biol­o­gy of mood dis­or­ders. Phar­ma­col­o­gy & Ther­a­peu­tics, 114(2), 222–232. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pharmthera.2007.02.003

    Dang, T., Uzoni, A., Kim, K., Clark, K., Layne, J., Lim, A. S., & Dueck, H. (2023). Risk for sea­son­al affec­tive dis­or­der (SAD) linked to cir­ca­di­an clock gene vari­ants. Biol­o­gy, 12(12), 1532. https://doi.org/10.3390/biology12121532

    Walk­er, W. H., Wal­ton, J. C., DeVries, A. C., & Nel­son, R. J. (2020). Cir­ca­di­an rhythm dis­rup­tion and men­tal health. Trans­la­tion­al Psy­chi­a­try, 10(1), 28. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41398-020‑0694‑0

    Edery, I. (2000). Cir­ca­di­an rhythms in a nut­shell. Phys­i­o­log­i­cal Genomics, 3(2), 59–74. https://doi.org/10.1152/physiolgenomics.2000.3.2.59

    Fran­cis, T. C., & Por­cu, A. (2023). Emo­tion­al­ly clocked out: cell-type spe­cif­ic reg­u­la­tion of mood and anx­i­ety by the cir­ca­di­an clock sys­tem in the brain. Fron­tiers in Mol­e­c­u­lar Neu­ro­science, 16, 1188184. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnmol.2023.1188184

    Jakubow­icz, D., Rosen­blum, J., & Wain­stein, J. (2023). Influ­ence of fast­ing until noon (extend­ed postab­sorp­tive state) on clock gene mRNA expres­sion and reg­u­la­tion of body weight and glu­cose metab­o­lism. Inter­na­tion­al Jour­nal of Mol­e­c­u­lar Sci­ences, 24(8), 7154. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijms24087154